Open Journal Systems

Markets for Promoting Innovation in Health Care? A Market Practice Study of Public Procurement of Innovation (PPI)

Nurgül Özbek, Linus Johansson Krafve, Hans Kjellberg, Ebba Sjögren

Abstract


This article critically analyzes public procurement of innovation (PPI) as an instance of using markets or market-like aspects as a means to resolve public concerns. It reports findings from a case of procuring radiation therapy equipment for a university hospital in Stockholm, Sweden. By extending a line of literature built on economic sociology as well as science and technology studies (STS), the study elaborates on public actors’ efforts in framing markets to promote innovation. The case illustrates how the participating actors constructed the notion of innovativeness to be introduced into health care as means of addressing various public concerns. It also reveals the intended—and unintended—consequences of PPI as manifested in various actors’ claims on the value of PPI realized in practice. The study suggests that it is extremely difficult to frame a market for the realization of innovation via procurement as a policy instrument because we cannot predict the ultimate impacts of devices and practices employed in such initiatives. By formulating a practice-based critique of PPI, our study invites important questions about the potentiality of such instruments for governing innovation without delimiting their consequences to the success-or-failure dichotomy as prescribed in predefined tools and strategies.


Keywords


Health Care; Innovation Governance; Market-based Instruments; Medical Technology; Public Procurement of Innovation (PPI)

Full Text:

PDF

References


Alvesson, M., & Sköldberg, K. (2017). Reflexive methodology: New vistas for qualitative research. London, Sage.

Arrowsmith, S. (2005) The Law of Public and Utilities Procurement, 2nd Ed. London, Sweet & Maxwell.

Aschhoff, B., & Sofka, W. (2009). Innovation on demand—Can public procurement drive market success of innovations? Research Policy, 38(8), 1235-1247.

Axelsson, O. (2021). Vill se mer innovationsupphandling. Upphandling24, April 9. https://upphandling24.se/vill-se-mer-innovationsupphandling/

Boon, W., & Edler, J. (2018). Demand, challenges, and innovation. Making sense of new trends in innovation policy. Science and Public Policy, 45(4), 435-447.

Caldwell, N., Walker, H., Harland, C., Knight, L., Zheng, J., & Wakeley, T. (2005). Promoting competitive markets: The role of public procurement. Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 11(5-6), 242-251.

Callon, M. (1998). An essay on framing and overflowing: Economic externalities revisited by sociology. The Sociological Review, 46(1), 244-269. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-954X.1998.tb03477.x

Callon, M. (2007). An essay on the growing contribution of economic markets to the proliferation of the social. Theory, Culture & Society, 24(7-8), 139-163.

Callon, M., Méadel, C., & Rabeharisoa, V. (2002). The economy of qualities. Economy and Society, 31(2), 194–217.

Callon, M., & Muniesa, F. (2005). Economic markets as calculative collective devices. Organization Studies, 26(8), 1229–1250.

Carlsson, L., & Andersson. L. (2015). Innovationsupphandling som framtidsverktyg (Innovation Procurement as a Future Tool Procurement). Presentation at Upphandling 2.0 Gothenburg 2015, September 23. https://upphandling24.event.idg.se/wp-content/uploads/sites/16/2015/09/NKS-Linda-Andersson-Lars-Carlsson.pdf

Chicot, J., & Matt, M. (2018). Public procurement of innovation: a review of rationales, designs, and contributions to grand challenges. Science and Public Policy, 45(4), 480-492.

Dagens Industri (2017). Elekta får hård kritik av landsting - kan mista jätteavtal. Dagens Industri, November 16. https://www.di.se/nyheter/elekta-far-hard-kritik-av-landsting-kan-mista-jatteavtal/

Dagens Medicin (2015). Så kan innovationsupphandling bli vägen till en bättre sjukvård. Dagens Medicin, October 14. https://www.karolinska.se/4af538/globalassets/global/4-gamla-kataloger/utveckling-och-innovation/innovationsupphandling_dagensmedicin.pdf

Dagens Nyheter (2019). Cancerpatienter i Stockholm skickas till Finland. Dagens Nyheter, July 23. https://www.dn.se/sthlm/cancerpatienter-i-stockholm-skickas-till-finland/

Diercks, G., Larsen, H., & Steward, F. (2019). Transformative innovation policy: Addressing variety in an emerging policy paradigm. Research Policy, 48(4), 880-894.

Doganova, L., & Eyquem-Renault, M. (2009). What do business models do? Innovation devices in technology entrepreneurship. Research Policy, 38(10), 1559-1570.

Doganova, L., & Karnoe, P. (2015). Clean and profitable: entangling valuations in environmental entrepreneurship. In A. B. Antal, M. Hutter & D. Stark (Eds.), Moments of Valuation: Exploring Sites of Dissonance. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

EC (2010). Europe 2020: A strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth, Communication from the Commission, COM(2010) 2020 final, 3 March. Brussels, European Commission. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:2010:2020:FIN:EN:PDF

EC (2016). Public procurement – a study on administrative capacity in the EU, Sweden Country Profile. Brussels, European Commission. https://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/sources/policy/how/improving-investment/public-procurement/study/country_profile/se.pdf

EC (2021). Guidance on Innovation Procurement, Brussels, European Commission. https://ec.europa.eu/docsroom/documents/45975

Edler, J., & Georghiou, L. (2007). Public procurement and innovation—Resurrecting the demand side. Research Policy, 36(7), 949-963.

EY (2014). Method book 1: Strategies and methods for effective innovation procurement in Sweden. Stockholm, EY and Karolinska University Hospital. https://assets.ey.com/content/dam/ey-sites/ey-com/sv_se/generic/pdf/ey-metodbok-1-strategier-och-metoder-for-effektiv-innovationsupphandling-i-sverige-med-fokus-pa-forkommersiell-upphandling.pdf

Frankel, C., Ossandón, J., & Pallesen, T. (2019). The organization of markets for collective concerns and their failures. Economy and Society, 48(2), 153-174.

Froste, C. (2017). Elekta håller inte måttet. Affärsvärlden, July 3. https://www.affarsvarlden.se/artikel/elekta-haller-inte-mattet-6859613

Guerzoni, M., & Raiteri, E. (2015). Demand-side vs. supply-side technology policies: Hidden treatment and new empirical evidence on the policy mix. Research Policy, 44(3), 726-747.

Geiger, S., & Gross, N. (2018). Market Failures and Market Framings: Can a market be transformed from the inside? Organization Studies, 39(10), 1357-1376.

Geiger, S., Harrison, D., Kjellberg, H. & Mallard, A. (2014). Concerned Markets: Economic ordering for multiple values. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

Georghiou, L., Edler, J., Uyarra, E., & Yeow, J. (2014). Policy instruments for public procurement of innovation: Choice, design and assessment. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 86, 1-12.

Godin, B., Gaglio, G., & Vinck, D. Eds. (2021). Handbook on Alternative Theories of Innovation. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Graells, A. S. (2015). Public procurement and the EU competition rules. London, Bloomsbury Publishing.

Grafström, M., Qvist, M., & Sundström, G. (2021). Megaprojektet Nya Karolinska Solna. Stockholm: Makadam Publishing.

Hall, P., & Löfgren, K. (2017). Innovation policy as performativity—the case of Sweden. International Journal of Public Administration, 40(4), 305-316.

Halloran, D. (2020). Evaluating social value in social clauses: Tensions in public procurement regulation and horizontal considerations. Doctoral dissertation, University of Galway.

Handler, H. (2015). Strategic Public Procurement: An Overview. For Europe - Policy Paper No. 28, 34 p. https://www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/125655

Johannesson, L., & Qvist, M. (2019). Ett megaprojekt tar form: Den tidiga planeringen av Nya Karolinska Solna. Score Report Series, 2019 (4).

Johansson Krafve, L. (2015). Valuation in Welfare Markets: The Rule Books, Whiteboards and Swivel Chairs of Care Choice Reform. Doctoral dissertation, Linköping University.

Juntti, G. (2019). Ledare: Regionens inkompetens drabbar hela Bottenviken. LT Södertälje Region, August 2. https://www.lt.se/2019-08-02/ledare-regionens-inkompetens-drabbar-hela-bottenviken

Karolinska (2022). About the NKS project. https://www.karolinska.se/om-oss/miljoer-for-vard-forskning-och-utbildning/toppmodernt-med-avancerad-vard/nks-projektet/

Kjellberg, H., & Helgesson, C. -F. (2006). Multiple versions of markets: Multiplicity and performativity in market practice. Industrial Marketing Management, 35(7), 839-855.

Kjellberg, H., & Helgesson, C. -F. (2007). On the nature of markets and their practices. Marketing Theory, 7(2), 137-162.

Kunzlik, P. (2013). Neoliberalism and the European Public Procurement Regime. Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies, 15, 283-356. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5235/152888713809813666

Lascoumes, P. & Le Gales, P. (2007). Introduction: Understanding public policy through its instruments – from the nature of instruments to the sociology of public policy instrumentation. Governance, 20(1), 1-21.

Laurent, B. (2021). Ideology, engine or regime. Styles of critique and theories of innovation. In Handbook on Alternative Theories of Innovation. Cheltenham, UK, Edward Elgar Publishing.

Lundberg, A. (2013). Skandalen Nya Karolinska. Stockholm: Timbro Publishing. https://timbro.se/app/uploads/2017/01/skandalen-nya-karolinska.pdf

Mazzucato, M. (2018). Mission-oriented innovation policies: challenges and opportunities. Ind. Corp. Change 27, 803-815.

Miller, F. A., & Lehoux, P. (2020). The innovation impacts of public procurement offices: The case of healthcare procurement. Research Policy, 49(7), 104075.

Muniesa, F., Millo, Y., & Callon, M. (2007). An introduction to market devices. In M. Callon, Y. Millo, & F. Muniesa (Eds.), Market Devices. London, Blackwell.

Neyland, D., Ehrenstein, V., & Milyaeva, S. (2019). Can markets solve problems?: an empirical inquiry into neoliberalism in action. London: Goldsmiths Press.

Nik-Khah, E., & Mirowski, P. (2019). On going the market one better: Economic market design and the contradictions of building markets for public purposes. Economy and Society, 48(2), 268-294.

Nordic Medtech Growth (2017). Value-based procurement. A report developed by the Nordic medical device industry associations within the project Nordic Medtech Growth. https://www.nordicinnovation.org/sites/default/files/inline-images/Value-Based%20Procurement%20%28VBP%29%20in%20the%20Nordic%20countries.pdf

OECD (2017). Public procurement for innovation: Good practices and strategies. OECD Public Governance Reviews. Paris, OECD Publishing.

Olsson, D., & Öjehag-Pettersson, A. (2020). Buying a sustainable society: The case of public procurement in Sweden. Local Environment, 25(9), 681-696.

RCC Stockholm Gotland (2016). Organisation av framtidens strålbehandling. Investigation by Regionalt cancercentrum. Stockholm, Gotland. https://cancercentrum.se/globalassets/vara-uppdrag/nivastrukturering/stockholm---gotland/organisation-av-framtidens-stralbehandling-20160930.pdf

Region Stockholm News (2018). Avtal för strålutrustning till Nya Karolinska Solna och Södersjukhuset. https://www.sll.se/verksamhet/halsa-och-vard/nyheter-halsa-ochvard/2018/02/Avtal-for-stralutrustning-till-Nya-Karolinska-Solna-och-Sodersjukhuset/

Reijonen, S., & Tryggestad, K. (2012). The dynamic signification of product qualities: on the possibility of “greening” markets. Consumption Markets & Culture, 15(2), 213-234.

SBU (2003). Strålbehandling vid cancer. Swedish Agency for Health Technology Assessment and Assessment of Social Services. https://www.sbu.se/sv/publikationer/SBU-utvarderar/stralbehandling-vid-cancer/

Svenska Dagbladet (2017). Ny cancerbehandling försenas – ”kommer aldrig hinna”. Svenska Dagbladet, May 22. https://www.svd.se/a/yAjle/ny-cancerbehandling-forsenas-kommer-aldrig-hinna

Svenska Dagbladet (2019). Region Stockholm: Det handlar om kompetensbrist Svenska Dagbladet, August 18. https://www.svd.se/a/y3Klpg/region-stockholm-vi-har-brist-pa-kompetens

SVT (2017). Elekta får svidande kritik av landsting. SVT News, November 16. https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/stockholm/elekta-far-svidande-kritik-av-landsting.

SVT (2018). Skandalerna som kantat Nya Karolinska. SVT News, May 25. https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/stockholm/nks.

Trepte, P. (2004). Regulating procurement: Understanding the ends and means of public procurement regulation. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Upphandlingsmyndigheten (2019a). Slutredovisning för uppdrag att främja innovationsupphandling genom stöd i form av upphandlings- och innovationskompetens för beställare. Final Report Government Assignment 2017-2018, Report 2019 (3). https://www.upphandlingsmyndigheten.se/globalassets/dokument/publikationer/uppdrag-att-framja-innovationsupphandling-190401.pdf

Upphandlingsmydigheten (2019b). Utvärdering 10 projekt inom innovationsupphandling. Report commissioned by Swedish Procurement Agency. https://www.upphandlingsmyndigheten.se/globalassets/dokument/upphandling/rapport-utvardering-10-projekt.pdf

Uyarra, E., Edler, J., Garcia-Estevez, J., Georghiou, L., & Yeow, J. (2014). Barriers to innovation through public procurement: A supplier perspective. Technovation, 34(10), 631-645.

Uyarra, E., Zabala-Iturriagagoitia, J. M., Flanagan, K., & Magro, E. (2020). Public procurement, innovation and industrial policy: Rationales, roles, capabilities and implementation. Research Policy, 49(1), 103844.

Vinnova (2009). Can public procurement spur innovation? Report by Copenhagen Economics. https://copenhageneconomics.com/publication/can-public-procurement-spur-innovation-in-health-care/

Vinnova (2020). Public sector innovation – the case of Sweden. Vinnova Report VR 2020 (2). https://www.vinnova.se/contentassets/9fab4046146e48379590a157481d3d7d/vr20-02eng.pdf

Webb, J., & Hawkey, D. (2017). On (not) assembling a market for sustainable energy: heat network infrastructure and British cities. Journal of Cultural Economy, 10(1), 8-20.

Wilkens, J., Thulesius, H., Schmidt, I., & Carlsson, C. (2016). The 2015 National Cancer Program in Sweden: Introducing standardized care pathways in a decentralized system. Health Policy, 120(12), 1378-1382.

Öjehag-Pettersson, A., & Granberg, M. (2019). Public procurement as marketisation: impacts on civil servants and public administration in Sweden. Scandinavian Journal of Public Administration, 23(3-4), 43-59.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5380/nocsi.v0i5.93604

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.